In order to raise awareness on Critical Raw Materials (CRM), the H2020 funded project BIORECOVER launched a communication campaign in June 2020. This campaign aims to inform and raise awareness among the European public on the challenges linked to the 30 CRMs identified by the European Commission, on the different forms which CRM take in our daily life, their importance for economic sustainability, and lastly, on the potential risks in terms of supply.

Introducing the BIORECOVER Project

What are CRMs?

According to the European Commission, Critical Raw Materials (CRMs) have a necessary use and are subject to supply restrictions. It is a variable notion over time that is expressed in two ways: the availability of the substance and its economic importance. Most of the time, it translates into a price signal that encourages economic actors to take steps to mitigate its effects, either by increasing availability (new resources) or by reducing needs (changes in technonological studies). The European Commission has listed 30 CRMs, which you can discover on the following images:

The EU is highly dependent on raw materials that are essential for its growth and competitiveness. Unexploited raw materials offer great potential but, the development of innovative extraction techniques is essential.

Throughout this campaign, you will discover how important CRMs are in our daily life, as they can be found in everyday life items. Then, we will underline why CRMs are important for the economy sustainability and the risks of supply. Finally, we will explain to you the implication of the Biorecover project, and how new technologies and innovation coming out of the project will ameliorate the current method of extraction.

Click to learn more about each CRM and their role in your daily life!

LEARN ABOUT ANTIMONY 

USES

Flame retardant

  • Antimony is used to prevent ignition in everyday objects, including plastics, cable coatings, and household appliances.

Battery efficiency

  • Antimony improves batteries’ charging characteristics and prevents the production of hydrogen during charging.

RECYCLABILITY

The recycling rate of antimony is estimated to be less than 10%. However, the 2015 Raw Material Supply Assessment Study suggests that the end of life-cycle recycling rate of antimony could reach 28%. Recycled antimony mainly comes from lead acid batteries. In most of its other uses, such as flame retardant, glasses, ceramics, antimony is too dispersed and therefore its recovery is not economically viable.

LEARN ABOUT BARYTE

USES

Oil and gas drilling

  • Baryte is used as a weighting agent for drilling fluids in oil and gas exploration. It suppresses high formation pressures and thus prevents blowouts.

Ability to block x-ray

  • Baryte is used to make high-density concrete that blocks x-ray emissions in hospitals, power plants and laboratories.

Ultracapacitor

  • Baryte is used to make ultracapacitors, an energy storage technology that offers high power density.

RECYCLABILITY

When used as a weighting agent in drilling project, baryte is recycled for re-use. But in most other applications, baryte is not recovered (fillers etc.) and cannot be recycled. Baryte used to make ultracapacitors, could be recycled in the future.

LEARN ABOUT BAUXITE

USES

Aluminum production:

  • Bauxite is the main source for the global manufacture of aluminum. Therefore, it is an essential raw material for many sectors such as mobility, defence or digital.

Safer road surfaces:

  • Calcined bauxite is used in roads to prevent accidents as it has high friction and anti-skid properties.

RECYCLABILITY

Bauxite used to create aluminium can very easily be recovered. Indeed, aluminium can be recycled many times without losing quality and recycling requires 30 times less energy than producing pure aluminium from bauxite. In other words, the energy required to produce one aluminium can from bauxite is the same as the energy required to produce up to 30 cans of recycled aluminium! Recycling aluminium is therefore essential to preserve bauxite. The Planet Mark Environmental Foundation reports that every tonne of aluminium that is recycled results in conserving five tonnes of bauxite!

LEARN ABOUT BERYLLIUM

USES

Nuclear applications

  • Beryllium is used in nuclear reactors as a reflector or moderator because it has a low thermal neutron absorption and a high melting point.

Defense and aerospace industries applications

  • Because of its stiffness and lightweight, beryllium is used in high-speed aircraft, spacecraft, and satellites.

RECYCLABILITY

Beryllium is not recycled from finished products due to the very small fraction of beryllium contained in end-products. However, beryllium is recovered from new waste scrap metal generated during manufacturing.

In 2013, secondary beryllium production from the recycling of new waste was between 100 and 135 tonnes, which is about 20% of global demand!

LEARN ABOUT BISMUTH

USES

Medical applications

  • Bismuth is an ingredient in some pharmaceuticals, used especially to treat stomach aches.

Lead substitute

  • As bismuth presents similar characteristics than Lead but with lower toxicity, it can replace it in applications such as plumbing, thus avoiding water contamination.

RECYCLABILITY

Bismuth is difficult to recycle because it is mainly used in many dissipative applications, such as pigments and pharmaceuticals. Still, the recycling of bismuth used in alloys is possible but currently underdeveloped. It could be recycled when used in brazing alloys found in electronic equipment for instance.

LEARN ABOUT BORATE

USES

Agricultural applications

  • Borate has fertilizing properties, as it contains essential nutrients for the growth of healthy plants. Also, it can be used to protect the wood from insects and rots thanks to its fungicidal and sporicidal properties.

High performance glass

  • Made with borate, glass is more durable as it is heat resistant, chemical resistant, and shock resistant.

RECYCLABILITY

Borate is mainly used in glass, ceramics production, and fertilizers. Recycling borates from these products is currently technologically not feasible because these uses are dispersive, or because it is not possible to separate borosilicate glass from boron-free container and flat glass.

LEARN ABOUT COBALT

USES

Material resistance

  • Cobalt is a strategic alloy for industrial applications that require high temperature and surface degradation resistance, such as gas turbines, space vehicles, or nuclear reactors.

Energy storing

  • Cobalt is also used to create accumulators, where energy can be stored for a later use.

Dietary Element

  • Cobalt is an essential dietary element for the growth of animals and micro-organisms. It is also used in biotechnology processes for diagnostics and pharmaceuticals.

RECYCLABILITY

Cobalt has an infinite recycling input rate. As a non-ferrous metal, Cobalt structural integrity does not degrade throughout the recycling process. Cobalt is one of the best recycled metals. The main source of refined cobalt is as a by-product of nickel (~50 %) and copper (~44%) which are in abundant supply, while a minority (~6%) is from primary cobalt mines.

LEARN ABOUT PLATINIUM GROUP METALS

USES

Pollution mitigation

  • Platinum is the main active component of automotive catalytic converters aiming at reducing harmful emissions.

Medical applications

  • Combined with osmium, platinum is used to create medical implants, such as pacemakers or artificial heart valves.

Electronic applications.

  • Thanks to their conductive properties, PMGs are used in eletronical fields.

Jewelry

  • Platinium can also be found in jewelry because it is corrosion resistant. Components can be converted into glass, under a high melting point temperature.

RECYCLABILITY

The recycling process of PGMs is already well developed from a technological point of view, and recycled PGMs satisfy a significant part of the gross demand of platinum (in 2010 it was equivalent to 28% of gross demand). End-of-life recycling rates for PGMs reach a global average of 50-60%, with recycled platinum keeping its specific properties up until its third recycling cycle.

Download poster here 

LEARN ABOUT COBALT

USES

Steel production

  • Coking coal, also known as metallurgical coal, is used to create coke, one of the key irreplaceable inputs for the production of steel. Steel, offering the highest strength-to-weight ratio, is an essential material for the construction and transport sectors.

RECYCLABILITY

It is not possible to recycle coking coal.

LEARN ABOUT FLUORSPAR

USES

Optic industry

  • Because of its high transparency and very low dispersion, fluorspar is often used to make high-quality camera, microscope and telescope lenses.

Coolant production

  • Fluorspar is used to make refrigerant systems used for vehicles, refrigerators, and air conditioners.

RECYCLABILITY

Fluorspar is not easily recyclable and therefore most fluorspar contained in waste mainly ends up in landfill. Still, in the coulant production sector, nearly 60 to 70% of fluorinated products are recycled!

LEARN ABOUT GALLIUM

USES

Communication applications

  • Gallium is widely used for radio frequency chipsets in mobile and satellite communication or laser diodes in fiber-based communication systems.

Medical applications

  • Gallium is also used in some radiopharmaceuticals, for detecting inflammation, infection or cancer.

RECYCLABILITY

Current waste recycling processes of end-users products such as chipsets, in which gallium could be retrieved, rather focus on the recovery of other precious metals like copper, and gallium ends up as an impurity of the metal recycling process. As with many other metals, recycling from industrial waste rather than from end-user products is more common for gallium and constitute a consequent secondary supply source.

LEARN ABOUT GERMANIUM

USES

Optical applications

  • Thanks to its high index of refraction and its low optical dispersion, germanium is especially useful to create wide-angle camera lenses, microscopy, as well as the core part of optical fibers. And, as germanium is also transparent to infrared radiation, it can be used to create night-vision devices or satellite imagery sensors.

RECYCLABILITY

The high price of refined germanium encourages recycling. It is estimated that around 30% of the world’s germanium production is supplied by recycling, mainly from waste generated during the manufacturing of fiber optic and infrared optics. But there is little recycling from old scrap and end of life products. Recycling only really occurs during the manufacture of germanium processed materials as the new scrap generated at this stage is directly reintroduced in the manufacturing. Indeed, due to the value of refined germanium, scrap is recovered and re-injected into the production process. However, recycling of old scrap remains low. This is due to dissipation and low-grade uses, as well as extra-terrestrial applications (solar cells for satellites) which cannot be collected.

LEARN ABOUT HAFNIUM

USES

Nuclear applications

  • Due to its high thermal neutron absorption cross-section and corrosion resistance qualities, hafnium is used in nuclear reactors control bars.

Lighting

  • Due to its heat resistance and its affinity to oxygen and nitrogen, hafnium is a good scavenger for oxygen and nitrogen in gas-filled and incandescent lamps.

RECYCLABILITY

Given its contamination in the industry and the low percentage content of superalloys, hafnium has barely any post-use recycling process.

LEARN ABOUT Rare Earth Elements

USES

Emerging technologies

  • REEs allow for the creation of permanent magnets which are essential to the efficient operation of large wind turbines and hybrid cars. REEs are also vital for other emerging technologies such as solid state fuel cells, superconductors, magnetic cooling or hydrogen storage.

Electronic goods

  • Those REE minerals are being used in the conception of magnets, compressors and motors, which is why you can find them in everyday items such as TV, smartphones, light bulbs, speakers, washing machines, or even air conditioners.

RECYCLABILITY

The EU end-of-life recycling input rate for REEs materials is very limited (only 7% for LREEs). The weak interest in recycling REEs is caused by the complexity of the recycling process. Indeed, REEs are usually incorporated as small components in complex items or as part of a complex material, making the recycling process energy intensive, economically costly and very complex.
Also, rare earths materials are very unlikely to be pure once recycled as separation chemistry remains a big challenge in most REE applications.

Download poster here 

LEARN ABOUT LITHIUM

USES

Battery production

  • Lithium is mainly used to create recheargeable batteries for electronic devices such as phones or laptops.

Medical applications

  • Lithium is useful in the treatment of a bipolar disorder or related diagnoses, such as schizoaffective disorder and cyclic major depression.

RECYCLABILITY

With the increasing demand for lithium, new technologies to recycle lithium from batteries are being developed. However, concerns remain regarding the purity of the recycled products, meaning that the recycled lithium is currently not reused to make new batteries. Currently, and because of low collection rate, the recycling rate for batteries containing lithium is only at 10% in Europe. This rate is meant to increase with the Commission’s Sustainable Batteries Regulation recycling target being set at 50% for lithium-ion batteries.

LEARN ABOUT INDIUM

USES

Tactile interface

  • Because it conducts electricity, bonds strongly to glass, and is transparent, indium is used to make touch screens.

Medical applications

  • Indium is sometimes used for fatigue, aging, boosting the immune system, and increasing hormone production.

RECYCLABILITY

Almost two third of refined indium comes from recycling. Indium from scrap generated by manufacturing process can be recycled quickly and turned into a product of the same quality as primary indium. However, recycling indium contained in end-of-life products such as cell phones or computers is currently not economically viable or technological feasible. The amount of indium per device is too small and the recycling technologies do not enable the separation of these special metals from the other materials.

LEARN ABOUT MAGNESIUM

USES

Electronics

  • Because of its low density and good mechanical and electrical properties, magnesium is used for the manufacturing of electronic devices such as mobile phones, laptop, and cameras.

Transport industry

  • Magnesium is the preference in all light-weighting vehicle concepts, being automotive, aircraft, or train. Mg components can be found in car seats, engine parts. It can also be used in ships, as components to prevent corrosion of iron and steel in pipes.

Pyrotechnics uses

  • Magnesium can generate a bright light which is why it is used in the creation of fireworks or sparklers.

RECYCLABILITY

The recycling of magnesium is technologically feasible and economically affordable. Recycling or reuse of scrap is common in the magnesium industry, reducing the demand of primary magnesium by up to 50%. However, the magnesium recycling rate for end-of-life products is quite low in the EU. Only 9 % of the available magnesium from end-of-life products goes to functional recycling, while 34 % is sent to disposal and 57 % ends up in non-functional recycling paths.

Download poster here 

LEARN ABOUT NATURAL GRAPHITE

USES

Lubricating properties

  • When a moving surface is under extremely high temperature or radiation, solid-state lubricants such as graphite must be used to replace traditional oil or fat.

Refractory applications

  • As graphite is a refractory material tolerating high temperatures, it is very useful to produce steel or glass.

RECYCLABILITY

As it can easily be separated from other materials and as contamination is not an issue, natural graphite can be successfully recycled. however, given the abundance of graphite in nature, recycling is currently not a priority and most of natural graphite contained in the end-of-life products ends up in landfill as hazardous waste.

LEARN ABOUT NATURAL RUBBER

USES

Medical applications

  • Natural rubber brings elasticity to products while creating a barrier to water. Therefore, it is especially useful in medicine for gloves, or to make catheters for instance.

Automotive

  • Natural rubber is mainly used for the production of tires, and other automotive components such as airbags.

RECYCLABILITY

The EU end-of-life recycling input rate for natural rubber is as low as only 1%. Indeed, due to contamination issues, recycled natural rubber loses the specific properties, making it impossible to reuse it for some applications. Thus, with the available technology, there is only very limited scope for recycling from product-to-new-product (ex. tyre-to-new-tyre), but rather from product-to-other-products requiring lower properties.

LEARN ABOUT NIOBIUM

USES

Superconducting properties

  • Niobium is used in various superconducting materials, such as magnets for MRI scanners and in particle accelerators.

Medical applications

  • Niobium is physiologically inert and hypoallergenic, thus it is used in prosthetics and implant devices, such as pacemakers.

RECYCLABILITY

Research is being conducted on how to improve the sorting of niobium from steel scrap. But at the moment, separating niobium present in the alloy makes the process too expensive and, thus, economically not convenient so almost no niobium is directly recovered. Still, niobium is recycled as part of recycling steel, and around 85% of steel is recycled worldwide.

LEARN ABOUT PHOSPHATE ROCK

USES

Agricultural applications

  • Phosphate rock is mainly used to make fertilizer, as it contains phosphorus, an essential plant nutrient. Fungicides and insecticides can also be made of Phosphate rock.

Food production

  • Phosphate is also used in animal-feed supplements and in food preservatives.

RECYCLABILITY

Given the limited amount of phosphate rock in the world, the growing difficulty to access new sources, and the difficulty to recycle phosphate rock, industries are looking at alternatives. Thus, phosphate rock is often replaced by secondary sources of phosphorus recycled, which show same quality as primary source phosphate rock.

LEARN ABOUT PHOSPHORUS

USES

Agricultural fertilizer

  • Phosphorus is essential for all living organism and thus is an important plant nutrient. It is involved in energy transfers, roots strength, and photosynthesis.

Metallurgical applications

  • Phosphorus is also an important component in the making of phosphor bronze, an alloy used for objects that must withstand various tensile stresses, wear or corrosion such as springs or screws.

RECYCLABILITY

Since recycled phosphorous has the same quality of the primary source of phosphate rock, it provides a promising solution to the disappearing phosphate rock reserves. Phosphorous is mainly recycled in agricultural processes and from biogenic waste flows such as food and vegetal waste, manure and sewage sludge. It has an end-of-life recycling input rate for around 17% in the EU.

LEARN ABOUT SCANDIUM

USES

Lightweight alloys

  • Scandium can be added to aluminum to increase its strength without increasing its weight, which is especially interesting for the aerospace industry.

Energy storage

  • Scandium can be used to create Solid Oxide Fuel Cells for energy storage.

RECYCLABILITY

Recycling scandium is currently economically not viable nor technologically feasible. No active recycling circuit currently exists for scandium, mainly because the cost of recycling is very high due to difficult separation process.

LEARN ABOUT SILICON METAL

USES

Steel production

  • Ferrosilicon, the most commonly used form of metallic silicon, is an important deoxidizing agent in the production of stainless steel.

Solar energy production

  • Silicon is essential to the photovoltaic industry. Today, 90 percent of solar energy is collected by silicon-based technology.

RECYCLABILITY

The huge annual growth in consumption of photovoltaics, where silicon is the dominant PV material, is boosting research activities to recover waste containing silicon. Some research shows that some procedures are able to recover silicon metal with more than 90% of purity. But yet, silicon metal is currently not recovered from post-consumer waste. The end-of-life recycling input rate is therefore 0%.

LEARN ABOUT STRONTIUM

USES

Pyrotechnics uses

  • Strontium is often used in ‘glow-in-the-dark’ paints, as it absorbs light during the day and releases it slowly for hours afterwards.

Electricity creation

  • Its high-energy radiation can be used to generate an electric current, and therefore Strontium is used in space vehicles or remote weather stations.

RECYCLABILITY

Technologies to recycled strontium are largely underdeveloped. Only residues resulting from the production of magnets are efficiently recycled for further use in magnet production. Indeed, the magnetic properties of recycled strontium ferrite powders are comparable to those of the starting material.

LEARN ABOUT TANTALUM

USES

Capacitor for electronic devices

  • Because tantalum can be used to coat other metals with a very thin layer, a high capacitance can be achieved in a small volume which makes it attractive for portable electronics such as mobile phones.

Medical applications

  • As it causes no immune response, tantalum can be used to replace bones, connect torn nerves or bind abdominal muscle.

RECYCLABILITY

Tantalum atoms can be recycled indefinitely and retain its elemental properties. As tantalum is a relatively high-value metal, it is almost fully recycled when possible, such as from in the superalloys used in jet engines for instance. But in some other applications, tantalum can be highly dissipated, making its identification, separation and aggregation for recycling challenging.

LEARN ABOUT TITANIUM

USES

Aerospace and defence

  • Because titanium alloys have high tensile strength, high corrosion resistance, and ability to withstand moderately high temperatures while being lightweight, they are used for spacecraft and missiles.

Medical applications

  • Because titanium is biocompatible (non-toxic and not rejected by the body), it is often used in medical implants.

RECYCLABILITY

Recycled titanium does not lose any specific properties and thus is essential to replace primary titanium. Currently, the end-of-life recycling input rate for titanium is more than 50%, but finding a viable way to recycle titanium was difficult. New technologies are now using advanced furnaces to reduce emissions and ensure that recycling titanium is less energy intensive than refining the primary metal.

LEARN ABOUT TUNGSTEN

USES

Cemented carbide

  • Because tungsten carbide is immensely hard, it is very important to the metal-working, mining and petroleum industries to create cutting and drilling tools for instance.

Electronics & electrical industries

  • Thanks to its high melting point, low vapor pressure, and conductive properties, tungsten is used for light bulbs and electrodes.

RECYCLABILITY

The end-of-life recycling input rate for Tungsten is at 42%. The tungsten processing industry can recycle almost every kind of tungsten-containing scrap, and as recycled tungsten keeps its specific properties and is already widely used by industries and plays an important part in the world’s tungsten supply.

LEARN ABOUT VANADIUM

USES

Energy stabilisation and production

  • Vanadium can stabilize the energy flow, which is still currently an issue in renewable energy production, such as wind turbines and solar panels. Vanadium can also be use to create batteries that have ten-times longer life-span than lithium-batteries, can charge and discharge simultaneously and are able to release huge amount of electricity instantly.

RECYCLABILITY

The end-of-life recycling input rate for Vanadium is 44%. Vanadium can be recovered and refined via several processes. It does not lose its specific properties and maintains the same quality of primary produced vanadium.

Why are CRMs important for the sustainability of our economy and what are the potential risks in terms of supply?

  • The expansion of renewable energy technologies such as electric car batteries and solar panels can be deeply impacted by a lack of REE.
  • As CRMs are mainly produced in China and because the demand is growing, geopolitical issues could appear if China decides to lower its volume of exports.
  • Business opportunities have appeared those past few years despite Europe’s dependence on foreign imports for CRMs and uncertainty towards supply, price volatility and market changes.
  • Europe’s environmental impacts caused by its reliance on foreign imports and mining, can be decreased through the recycling of waste for a more sustainable use of CRMs.
  • European countries have to find replacements and establish new, innovative, clean, and sustainable technologies in order to extract and transform CRMs.

Download poster here 

What is the BIORECOVER project and how will it address CRMs?

BIORECOVER’s main objective is based on the research and development of a new sustainable and safe process, essentially based on biotechnology, for selective extraction of a wide range of Critical Raw Materials. To do so, the project will use three processes:

  • Pre-treatment: The objective is to increase the concentration of the CRMs present in the matrices. This objective is achieved removing the following impurities:

Iron (Fe), Aluminium (Al), Calcium (Ca) and Titanium (Ti) for BR

Silicon (Si), Iron (Fe) and CaCO3 for MgW

Cupper (Cu), Nickel (Ni) and Cobalt (Co) for PLGO

Cupper (Cu), Nickel (Ni), Zinc (Zn) and Iron (Fe) for PCBP

The removing in the raw material will be carried out by specific microbial action:

  • Treatments: The CRMs will put in contact with different microorganisms depending on the metal that we want to get. There are several quantities of microorganism used for this type of process.
  • Post-Treatments: To recover the CRMs from bioleachate with high selectivity and purity. Five treatments will be carried out in principle:
  1. Microcapsules
  2. Microalgae
  3. Bacterial
  4. Fungi
  5. Proteins